Leominster RSS Feed Send your news, pictures & videos


Community Banner

Leominster building firm, John Ruck Construction, criticises tendering process for Hereford cattle market


A BUILDING firm has criticised the tendering process to build Hereford’s new cattle market.

Bosses at John Ruck Construction (JRC) are fuming after being told they applied to do the work 24 hours too late.

But they claim they sent numerous emails and made up to a dozen phonecalls before the deadline.

The Leominster firm has now been informed by the main contractor, Willmott Dixon, that the steel, cladding and roofing packages they wanted to build have been offered elsewhere.

“This sort of job is our bread and butter but we were not given a chance to quote,” said company boss John Ruck.

“We got in contact with Willmott Dixon, met them at a Meet The Contractors day, and were told we would have the opportunity to quote.

“But we didn’t receive the documents despite numerous phonecalls, emails and promises they would get back to us.”

He said Hertfordshire-based Willmott Dixon, appointed by Herefordshire Council to oversee the construction work at the site near Stretton Sugwas, told him there was a degree of urgency to get work started.

“They said they had to get the steel on site within 15 weeks but we could have done it in eight,” added Mr Ruck, whose company has built other cattle markets in both Bridgnorth and Cirencester.

“We are capable of doing the work and had good references. It just makes me feel aggrieved.”

Willmott Dixon told the Hereford Times that JRC first contacted them a day after offers from interested parties were due in and there was little they could do.

“It was decided that the very quick timescales for the project meant we did not have enough time to undertake a full re-enquiry,” said Willmott Dixon’s head of communications, Andrew Geldard.

He said another Leominster firm, Frank H Dale, had been given permission to design the steelwork with the steel package due to be announced soon.

Mr Geldard said his colleagues had since offered to send JRC enquiries for the cladding and roofing packages - worth a total of more than half a million pounds - but said they didn’t want those contracts unless they had the steel one too. They are now due to be awarded. to a Hereford-based contractor.

Comments(3)

phxweb says...
12:03am Sat 24 Jul 10

Deadline is a deadline!! GCSE and Uni Coursework have deadlines, If its after the deadline its after the deadline and its tough luck ...

Poor Management not getting the tender in on time .... not really news this just incompetence

leftofmoorfarm says...
8:26pm Sat 24 Jul 10

Well said phxweb, see also the HT "story" about a man not buying enough stamps and trying to blame his lack of planning on the Post Office.

davidtphillips says...
6:06pm Tue 27 Jul 10

No-one likes to criticise lousy British management more than me - but I understood that John Ruck Construction did not receive the necessary papers through which they could submit their offer even though they repeatedly asked for them.

Therefore I smell a rat in the tendering process, and surely they can appeal if they have evidence of their communications?


John Ruck with emails sent to Wilmott Dixon. Buy this photo icon Buy this photo » John Ruck with emails sent to Wilmott Dixon.

Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses