Heated meeting to discuss £500,000 council retail payment (From Hereford Times)
Get involved! Send your photos, video, news & views by texting HT NEWS to 80360 or e-mail us
Heated meeting to discuss £500,000 council retail payment
1:03pm Friday 9th November 2012 in News
THE granting of an extra half a million pounds to Hereford's controversial retail and leisure complex has been at the centre of a heated debate this morning.
Members of Herefordshire Council's Overview and Scrutiny Committee discussed the reasons behind cabinet's recent approval of £500,000 towards Old Market developer Stanhope.
The funding shortfall has come about after the scheme's funding partner British Land said market conditions mean it needs to see a change in the financial return it gets from the complex.
Changes to the funding deal means Stanhope expects to receive around £3m less from British Land, meaning they have asked the council to contribute the £500,000 towards the shortfall.
Five recommendations were agreed by Scrutiny during the meeting at the council's Brockington HQ.
They include asking Cabinet, when it meets to discuss the matter on Monday, what steps have been taken to safeguard the council's position under European Procurement laws and ensuring risks are segregated between those that apply to Stanhope and the council.
Scrutiny also wants Cabinet to prove value for money by showing further due diligence and ensure the reasons behind commercial confidentiality are carefully considered.
- Here's how we covered it live - Herefordshire Council's scutiny committee meeing
Comments(62)
fmrbill
says...
1:53pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Biomech
says...
2:00pm Fri 9 Nov 12
shunter50
says...
2:53pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
3:11pm Fri 9 Nov 12
I hope they at least realise that they need to be more accountable and transparent. I eagerly await the outcome of the meeting on Monday.
In response to fmrbill, I agree low cost housing is required and parking is a sensible suggestion but currently there is little reason for people to visit hereford anyway so we essentially could end up with an empty car park. We need redevelopment desperately but the way HC have approached this and are continuing to handle this is nothing short of atrocious and, with this bung to Stanhope, could actually be illegal. As Colin pointed out on another post, we need real alternatives and as far as I understand there is no Plan B and they're so far into this they can't back out.
Oh and another +1 for Jarvis out ;)
fmrbill
says...
3:18pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Just another point that interesting article in the HT about the Local Parish Council and FOI request being refused. Anyone thought about requesting the minutes of the meeting for all the secretive meeting regarding new excutitives and this development, let HC refuse and then let the FOI Commissioner decide. I bet minutes have even been kept. Any one got the time or inclination to take this on. WHAT ABOUT KING BOBBY47 the leader of a new army !!!!!
dippyhippy
says...
3:41pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Biomech
says...
3:51pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Herefordian
says...
4:50pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Grid Knocker
says...
4:55pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Wellymitts
says...
6:46pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Another +1 for jarvis sacking.
billyb83
says...
7:21pm Fri 9 Nov 12
littlewhitebull
says...
7:51pm Fri 9 Nov 12
By the way - I came across a website today called www.hereyoucan.co.uk
Do have a look, if you have not seen it before. Our council has spent almost £22,000 on its design and management!
At a time when they are "cash-strapped" and borrowing millions, they can somehow afford the money to fund another self-serving device.
Lukio
says...
8:17pm Fri 9 Nov 12
Looking through the website and guidelines there's some serious work going into this...well spotted littlewhitebull.
Love the way they give examples of how you can use the 'Here you can' slogan!
Here's some of my 'Here you can' ideas:
'Here you can' bust your suspension on potholes
'Here you can' keep throwing thousands at a questionable developer
'Here you can' spend £12000 on bottled water
'Here you can' refuse local business property on the Enterprise Zone
'Here you can' have failed child protection services
'Here you can' hold as many secret meetings as you like
'Here you can' have a tantrum about people texting during a council meeting
'Here you can' hike parking charges
'Here you can' close public toilets
'Here you can' waste hours of your life sat in traffic
'Here you can' give your outgoing chief exec massive renumeration packages
Ahhh I could go on but I expect you're all getting bored of me by now ;)
bobby47
says...
8:43pm Fri 9 Nov 12
dippyhippy
says...
9:48pm Fri 9 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
10:00pm Fri 9 Nov 12
For my part, I'll go along with anything that kicks this Coucil into the new reality that we are broke and we cant afford gimmicks and anymore mistakes.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
10:08pm Fri 9 Nov 12
littlewhitebull - where did £22k come from - are you sure you it wasn't £220k - this amount of interactive buzz bull would certainly have cost more than £22k.
dippyhippy
says...
10:14pm Fri 9 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
10:25pm Fri 9 Nov 12
I promise you that they do read this stuff and what we are saying is having an impact but.......
One way or the other, we all have to reach a point where we break cover, organise ourselves because HT aint going to make us the news unless we create it.
Thats the problem and I know that Lukio is reluctant to be in the limelight, so, we are where we are for the time being.
Personally speaking, my view is that 'we' have to make some contact with a Councillor who is a dead certainty to be on our side and then we have to break cover and cross our fingers that the Council dont go to war with us.
Sleep on it kiddo. Twowheels and the rest will read this exchange and Im sure we will come to a decision soon.
My warmest regards.
bobby47
says...
10:58pm Fri 9 Nov 12
The problem is we have to make a move and untill we do and its a collective thing then we aint really going anywhere.
We have to do something thats different. We either get one of our number to contact a Councillor and then sit back and see where fate takes us or we all agree to break cover, meet and take things from there.
What we are doing now is great, it really is some achievement and we should be pleased with ourselves but, as things stand at the moment, we aint really going to progress this momentum.
For my part, I feel like I know everyone and I dont feel the need to know a face behind the Poster and become your bestest Saturday night drinking buddy. Friends I got. I dont want anymore friends. For me, this is business and getting rid of this Council.
We either carry on as we are and I aint got a problem with that or we change our course and do something different.
Discuss!!!!
littlewhitebull
says...
9:58am Sat 10 Nov 12
A London company was commissioned to "design" the signs on our county's borders - cost = £15,020.06.
"Research" into "development of a brand" = £12,000.
These figures are facts. More information to come in near future!!!!
Hope I haven't spoiled your well-earned weekends.
megilleland
says...
10:16am Sat 10 Nov 12
littlewhitebull wrote:"In an attempt to boost tourism, councillors are considering re-branding the town Funbridge Wells. Other slogans up for discussion include ‘Why not Tunbridge Wells?’ and ‘Cultural Capital of West Kent’."
I was talking to a group of senior citizens in our city today. They expressed some very strong feelings about the direction the council is taking. To say they were not happy bunnies would be an understatement. All of these senior citizens stressed that they thought our council was wasteful and would like to see a change of direction as soon as possible.
By the way - I came across a website today called www.hereyoucan.co.uk
Do have a look, if you have not seen it before. Our council has spent almost £22,000 on its design and management!
At a time when they are "cash-strapped" and borrowing millions, they can somehow afford the money to fund another self-serving device.
HC are not the only ones thinking of burning tax payers money on rebranding!
http://www.dailymail
.co.uk/news/article-
2230817/Welcome-Funb
ridge-Wells-Council-
wants-brand-Kent-tow
n-attract-tourists.h
tml
littlewhitebull
says...
12:58pm Sat 10 Nov 12
Possibly, one of the most bizarre examples was in Bristol. The city had an excellent industrial museum called the ‘M Shed’. The museum needed a great deal of work, so the council spent millions overhauling and upgrading the building. But, they felt the name of ‘M Shed’ was a bit naff, and employed an outside agency to come up with a new name.
This company spent months (apparently) toying with ideas for a flash new name for the museum. Eventually, after receiving their fee of £100,000, the company told Bristol Council that they could not come up with a better name than the original ‘M Shed’.
I am definitely going to apply for a job with the “True North” advertising company.
Biomech
says...
1:11pm Sat 10 Nov 12
However,I'd like to see the cost break down for that websites £22,000. I do work as a web developer and that is potentially £18-20,000 more than I would have charged for what it is.
Maybe I need to raise my pricing!
littlewhitebull
says...
2:14pm Sat 10 Nov 12
"The total cost to design, host and manage the interactive website is £21,821.25."
Good luck with your work, and perhaps HC could place the work locally with people like you?
I am sure 'You Can' do the work better for a fraction of the cost.
Biomech
says...
2:31pm Sat 10 Nov 12
Unfortunately, as I've mentioned in other articles, I get the bulk of my work from outside of Hereford - because, quite frankly, Hereford is useless :) The only reason I still live here isdue to logistics, it's balanced between the M5, M4, A40 and A49 which makes it great for getting to my clients :P
William Rudd
says...
3:59pm Sat 10 Nov 12
Yeah all five of you lol.
Its going ahead,it will be built..Nuf said
Biomech
says...
4:09pm Sat 10 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
4:30pm Sat 10 Nov 12
This is bigger than regeneration now. Yes, HC have seemingly ballsed it up monumentally and it's now become a vanity project but it's not just regeneration they're failing on. It's a massively long list. If people can't see it then they're blind.
And to prove William wrong, as I'm pretty sure he is, can we get a nod of concurrence from the HT that they do read these comments? It would be good for King Bobby ;)
bobby47
says...
4:55pm Sat 10 Nov 12
My best regards.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
5:05pm Sat 10 Nov 12
littlewhitebull
says...
3:30pm Sun 11 Nov 12
Biomech wrote:It's a pity our council does not use the skills of the people already living here - like yourself, Biomech.
lol :) Thank you. Hey, even if I charged them £15,000 they would still be saving :P
Unfortunately, as I've mentioned in other articles, I get the bulk of my work from outside of Hereford - because, quite frankly, Hereford is useless :) The only reason I still live here isdue to logistics, it's balanced between the M5, M4, A40 and A49 which makes it great for getting to my clients :P
As you are in the business of web development, what did you actually think of the HC website - hereyoucan?
If you compare it with say - www.investindevon.co
.uk - it seems to me that Devon offers some very useful contacts and help that would be very useful to businesses. i.e. a lot of relevant info. Perhaps, this is a rather unfair comparison as hereyoucan is a different concept?
Good to hear your views on this Biomech.
Biomech
says...
4:04pm Sun 11 Nov 12
This kind of thing is something you see in private company intranets. At most, it would have sufficed as a page or two on a main, already established website.
The design isn't great, but I'm sure you can see that. It's like a small scribble on a big white page. The quotes page is a good example, there's a lot of wasted space - which makes the page appear unnecessary.
They make a big deal about photography being huge in the brand. The photography in the PDF isn't that great and has some harsh chromatic Aberration (purple/green fringing). More over, however, they state they have set up a flickr group to act as a community for photos/sharers in Hereford, yet provide no link. Instead you have to email them for more information.
The code isn't efficient either. I mean look at what you have. 1 carousel that you can get the code for free ANYWHERE on the net. Under that, a poor page of quotes, a list of contacts and a paragraph about photos. Then a PDF link that they probably didn't make themselves. There is actually nothing there for anyone but insider businesses (registration required might I add)
Devon - I haven't plowed through, but at a quick glance, it's thinner than I would have it, but it looks packed with information. It tells you right there on the homepage what the site is for and provides great navigation and structure to the sections making it easier to find what you want.
But you are right, the Devon site is a public fronted sales pitch. The Hereford site is basically an internal guide on how to use the here you can logos.
Biomech
says...
4:08pm Sun 11 Nov 12
littlewhitebull
says...
5:01pm Sun 11 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
5:21pm Sun 11 Nov 12
Basically, in the up coming Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) elections we need to vote for, and it pains me to say, Adrian Blackshaw. He is the Tory councillor for Wormsley Ridge.
Although this goes against all my beliefs, it may pave the way for change. If he is successful, it will lead to a by-election in the Wormsley Ridge ward. IF an opposition party wins the seat, we'll have a hung council as the Tories won't have majority any more.
I don't know how you feel about this and I'd NEVER vote Tory in anything but this may be the chance we need.
Spread the word, change is upon us.
Biomech
says...
5:39pm Sun 11 Nov 12
littlewhitebull wrote:Thanks :)
Thanks, Biomech. Very interesting to have an opinion from a person in the 'know'. I don't disagree with anything you say. Many thanks. Good luck with your business.
Wellymitts
says...
6:52pm Sun 11 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
7:33pm Sun 11 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
7:42pm Sun 11 Nov 12
It makes sense Bobby! I know you can do it!
Biomech
says...
8:01pm Sun 11 Nov 12
Yeah, about as democratic as telling you you are going to have a terminal disease but you have a choice, cancer or tumour. Hey, you can't complain, you get to choose!
bobby47
says...
8:11pm Sun 11 Nov 12
dippyhippy
says...
9:29pm Sun 11 Nov 12
dippyhippy
says...
9:29pm Sun 11 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
10:13pm Sun 11 Nov 12
TwoWheelsGood
says...
5:35pm Mon 12 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
6:32pm Mon 12 Nov 12
Never a break. Never a single boost.
megilleland
says...
11:25pm Mon 12 Nov 12
5th May 2011
BARTRUM, CHRISTOPHER MARK 617 (Elected)
Liberal Democrats
LUCAS, GORDON 597 (Elected)
Local Conservatives
TEAGUE, MARILYN ANN 522
Independent
SINCLAIR POWELL, MARY ANN 503
Independent
GIBBS, NIGEL THOMAS 383
Local Conservatives
HUGHES, PATRICK 368
Liberal Democrats
BROWN, MARGARET DOROTHY BARNARD 97
It's OUR County (Herefordshire)
megilleland
says...
11:28pm Mon 12 Nov 12
5th May 2011
BLACKSHAW, ADRIAN JAMES MICHAEL 603 (Elected)
(Known as Adrian Blackshaw)
Local Conservatives
JONES, MICHAEL JOHN 385
(Known as Mike Jones)
Independent
DU HEAUME, MARY KYRLE 120
(Known as Kyrle du Heaume)
Green Party
megilleland
says...
11:35pm Mon 12 Nov 12
apdor
says...
10:58am Thu 15 Nov 12
News papers should report a balanced view rather than the sensational unbalance which sells papers !
In terms of the revenue the New ESG will bring into the county 1/2 a million is basically nothing.
As for the 'Here You Can Brand' the site is for businesses to access the resources so they can promote their brands and help promote the city ! I agree that the £20000 is over the top for a simple web design, but if this figure also includes all the logo designs etc used then I think this would be acceptable.
Roads - The A and B Roads are better than they were 5 years ago (if you really think about it !)
Unfortunately the Labour government spent all our money, now the Local Councils are having to tighten there belts and make cuts. The council is amongst these cuts trying to grow the city and give it some potential so that it doesnt become a glorified Old peoples home.
I don't proclaim they are doing everything right, there is much that can be improved! but the shops in High town which have gone bust is nothing to do with the council. A recession sorts out the businesses that are badly managed and scrape buy in the Good years. most businesses I know are growing this year! Those that are not are doing something wrong. !
The problem is the other parties as with all politics shout and ball about the opposition but actually have no meat around the ideas they have to do better!
apdor
says...
11:19am Thu 15 Nov 12
The developer was going to pay HC 1.5 Million as a end of build pay off.
Now they are only going to give 1million, This is not money the council have given away.
As normal the Hereford Times have failed to report accurately the news !
TwoWheelsGood
says...
11:28am Thu 15 Nov 12
Wellymitts
says...
11:37am Thu 15 Nov 12
apdor
says...
11:42am Thu 15 Nov 12
What bias would i have ? I run my own business, and offered my opinion. Which every one is entailed to do !
Wellymitts - I didnt say they were not bad ... i said that compared to 5 years ago they are better.
dippyhippy
says...
2:36pm Thu 15 Nov 12
megilleland
says...
10:19am Fri 16 Nov 12
I don't proclaim they are doing everything right, there is much that can be improved! but the shops in High town which have gone bust is nothing to do with the council. A recession sorts out the businesses that are badly managed and scrape buy in the Good years. most businesses I know are growing this year! Those that are not are doing something wrong
Walking through Maylords yesterday and notice that Jessops is closing at the end of the month, must be doing something wrong!
megilleland
says...
10:28am Fri 16 Nov 12
Biomech
says...
12:19pm Fri 16 Nov 12
I'm sure the HT do spin some stories to make headlines, but you only need to stick your head out of the window to see that Hereford has failed.
Also, in the interest of public service, it's 12.20 lunch time Friday and I've just been told Whitecross Road is gridlocked again, so I'd avoid that route if you can.
bobby47
says...
12:46pm Fri 16 Nov 12
It's crazy and deluded thinking. The only way this could be justified is if they secured a wire from the Black and White House to Lloyds Bank and they dressed Jarvis in some brightly decorated caped costume and forced him up the ladder and be made to walk the wire without a safety net.
What are this Council thinking!
It's like the running of Rome. Put on some gladiator games and entertain the masses and let them forget their bloody misery for a long weekend.
We are bloody doomed.
megilleland
says...
8:28pm Fri 16 Nov 12
fordshire77 says...
1:27pm Fri 9 Nov 12
I CAN SAVE THEM A STACK OF CASH.......STARTING WITH THE SACKING JARVIS!!