Special meeting: Hereford's old cattle market (From Hereford Times)
Get involved! Send your photos, video, news & views by texting HT NEWS to 80360 or e-mail us
Special meeting: Hereford's old cattle market
7:41am Wednesday 31st October 2012 in News
By Mark Bowen
Enable automatic updates every 30 seconds? YES NO
Latest
- Herefordshire Council this morning held a special cabinet meeting on the future of Hereford's old cattle market
- Members have approved a new funding arrangement to ensure the development still goes ahead
- The council will waive £500,000 it would have received
- British Land has agreed to relax some of its original conditions
12:36pm
Herefordshire Council has just released this statement:
THE Leader of Herefordshire Council, Councillor John Jarvis called a special meeting of Cabinet today (31 October) at which final changes to the contract to develop the Old Market site in Hereford have been agreed.
Cabinet discussed changes to the initial agreement between the developers of the site (Stanhope plc) and British Land plc. With preparatory works and demolition underway, the meeting successfully resolved the few remaining conditions, paving the way for construction to begin on the new retail development imminently.
The changes include that the council will waive £500,000 of money it would have received from the deal and that British Land will agree to relax some of its original conditions before the funding is released. Stanhope has also agreed to reduced returns from the deal and will bear additional costs that were not known at the outset. The discussion today has come about in response to changes in the market value of the development. By agreeing to the variations, the cabinet has ensured the Council will receive £1.5million from the developers as a capital receipt, before returning its £500,000 waiver.
Nothing in the proposal has changed the agreement on lettings, which is in place to protect the economy of the existing city centre and with today’s news, critically, all three parties are now locked into the development; a major milestone for the project.
Councillor Jarvis said: “We all negotiated very hard and I believe we have managed to deliver a really good deal for the City and the County. Everyone has made concessions but today’s agreement now means the only retail scheme to open in the UK in 2014 will be here in Hereford.
“This development will generate more than 1,000 jobs, in addition to the jobs during the construction phase. It will lead to £1.25million of business rates income to the Council along with the income from the new car park on the site. The Council will still retain the car park as a capital asset.”
Alistair Shaw from Stanhope commented: “This is a critical last step in bringing to fruition the first funding deal of its kind to be agreed in the UK for more than five years; a deal which will bring about a real boost for the county. The commitment being shown in Hereford, and in agreeing this landmark deal, is exciting for all parties and for the residents and businesses of the city. Everyone has had to make significant contributions to make this deal happen, but we are delighted with the cabinet’s decision, which serves as evidence of our shared vision for Hereford’s future.”
10:51am
Vote goes in favour of cabinet meaning Stanhope gets additional £500k.
10:48am
Coun Hubbard says "the £500k is not essential for this deal. It is just propping up Stanhope's profit."
10:45am
Coun James tells cabinet "You are swimming in a shark pool and they are taking advantage of you. For goodness sake stand firm."
10:43am
Coun James says the project is 'bleeding the county for £50m."
10:40am
Coun Terry James tells the cabinet they are pumping money into a private development.
10:37am
Coun Matthews says Stanhope "should pick up the bill and get on with it."
10:36am
Coun Bob Matthews says he is not against modernising and if the project goes ahead people will try to make it work.
10:31am
Coun Hubbard tells cabinet if they were putting their own money into the project they would apply "a lot more common sense."
10:29am
Coun Hubbard: "I said this would happen in July that is a fact."
10:27am
Coun Hubbard wants full council to make the decision.
10:25am
Coun Mark Hubbard says he would like the term 'value for money' to be clarified.
10:23am
Coun Phillip Price says the deal stil represents value for money.
10:21am
Coun Russell B Hamilton says "the amount we are being asked to waive will be repaid mutiple times over."
10:17am
Coun Harry Bramer urges cabinet to accept proposal because a refusal would put any project back 'five or 10 years'.
10:07am
Coun leader Jarvis fears Hereford will be left with a large car park if no agreement is reached today.
10:05am
Council leader John Jarvis describes today meeting as 'urgent' and says he will stop the meeting if there are any interruptions from public gallery.
10:01am
Today's meeting is now underway.
9:57am
Cabinet members are gathered at the council HQ. Many other councillors are hear to listen to the meeting.
9:04am
Comments(63)
Themightyboosh
says...
10:23am Wed 31 Oct 12
they still are not shure what the hell is going on.
i have the distinct feeling the chief exec could not find their backsides with both hands and a map.
i truly despair.
heads should roll.
Lukio
says...
10:24am Wed 31 Oct 12
Themightyboosh
says...
10:27am Wed 31 Oct 12
Lukio wrote:Council leader John Jarvis describes today meeting as 'urgent' and says he will stop the meeting if there are any interruptions from public gallery.
Are the public allowed to ask questions during a meeting like this?
i guess thats a no
cursor
says...
10:30am Wed 31 Oct 12
Moreteavicar?
says...
10:32am Wed 31 Oct 12
Themightyboosh
says...
10:50am Wed 31 Oct 12
see them signing away one kidney and the first born son from every council tax payer here.
Poledb
says...
10:53am Wed 31 Oct 12
cursor
says...
11:03am Wed 31 Oct 12
Poledb wrote:An additional £500K isn't going to go very far.
This has been a complete farce from the start.This Council just does what it wants and disregards anyone else,particularly us the Council tax payers.Why do we bother electing Councillors when the hierarchy on the council just disregard the elected councillors,who are actually in touch with local people.If we have to have a development on the old market site it would have made more sense to move Tesco there from Bewell Street.Perhaps then we could move the Council offices there instead of the inaccessible Franklin house.There would still be room for a cinema and restaurants and car parking at the old market and also more parking and a bus service station from the old Tesco site.Where do these top councillors come from?Cloud cuckoo land?It certainly is not from Herefordshire.How do they expect local people to afford to shop in Waitrose etc.The heart is being ripped out of the city centre just to satisfy someones overlarge ego.
Lukio
says...
11:23am Wed 31 Oct 12
oldergit
says...
11:50am Wed 31 Oct 12
fordshire77
says...
12:35pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Herefordian07
says...
1:16pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Gillian1961
says...
1:32pm Wed 31 Oct 12
SethStarkadder
says...
1:56pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Themightyboosh wrote:Wow!
the way this council negotiates i can
see them signing away one kidney and the first born son from every council tax payer here.
Great income generating idea
Someone should suggest it to the next Council meeting
bobby47
says...
2:17pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Before I was a bloody HT Poster I lead a normal life, fishing, spending time with me kids, reading Jordan's most recent biography and playing with my grandkids. I'm going back to my old life before I end up climbing into the oven with the lumps of dough I knead day in, day out, over and over again.
This bloody Council will never stop wasting our money and my bloody time.
To all the demented ranters and ravers. To the possessed, the dispossessed, those with clubbed feet, the Toad Sexers down Yazor Brooke and of course those who are still able to string a thought and sentence together that dont refer to 'the bloody Council', I say goodbye, a fond farewell and offer up my very warmest best wishes.
IM DONE. RETIRED FROM ACTIVE DUTY. Bloody Counci!
Patley
says...
2:24pm Wed 31 Oct 12
TwoWheelsGood
says...
3:31pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Herefordian07
says...
4:25pm Wed 31 Oct 12
gedina
says...
4:55pm Wed 31 Oct 12
This will hopefully throw up any 'special relationships' that are held between them and other business owners who may have a stake in the future of Hereford.
If any are shown, and any link to backhanders, favousrism and other 'special treatment' then the appropriate legal action can be instigated.
Many people in public life seem to think that they are above the law, only a thorough investigation into each of these individuals can help to see if they are related to the tooth fairy or not.
Lukio
says...
5:37pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Is anyone on Facebook and friends with Hereford Futures? The amount of spin they've put on this is unbelievable!
TwoWheelsGood
says...
5:57pm Wed 31 Oct 12
William Rudd
says...
8:35pm Wed 31 Oct 12
When ever I need a good laugh to cheer me up you lot give it to me with both barrels.
Lukio
says...
10:00pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Tim Bray
says...
10:06pm Wed 31 Oct 12
Patley wrote:Yes there is a way. However, it involves the great unwashed of Herefordshire getting up and voting come the next election, not just leaving it to the 20 or 30% of faithful Tory blue rinsers who habitually vote the buggers back in every time!
Absolutely disgusting! Is there no way we can rid ourselves of these biggots who have no respect for the electorate or the county?
Lukio
says...
6:40am Thu 1 Nov 12
However, is there a real alternative to the Tories? I think It's Our County have a chance to take seats but they need to up their game to convince Herefordians that they are a viable alternative. Props to Mark Hubbard and the various Independants who asked serious and sensible questions yesterday. You guys have an opportunity to increase your seats next time round and I think you need to start working on your strategies now.
Yesterday's shenanigans prove further that the system is rotten to the core and that this runaway gravy train is heading for a crash. Sadly, it will be at detriment of the council tax payer and will scupper the future of Hereford for generations. And those responsible will scuttle off into obscurity with chunky renumeration packages not knowing or caring about the damage they've caused.
William Rudd
says...
12:37pm Thu 1 Nov 12
After the Hubbard-Bull farce a few years ago they ain't got no chance.
Lukio
says...
1:55pm Thu 1 Nov 12
So you're in total support of the council again? Funny how you only come on here when it's anything to do with this subject. So which councillor/cabinet member are you then?
If you really think this lot are doing a good job you're either totally deluded or a complete knob.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
4:34pm Thu 1 Nov 12
nt/whatever and it would have been a very different picture. Such is democracy.
The press statement at the top of this page is a masterpiece of spin, and presumably written before the meeting. I still fail to see how 5 shops will create 'more than 1000 jobs' - even 100 would be pushing it.
Lukio
says...
5:59pm Thu 1 Nov 12
Problem is most people will get caught up in the spin - like poor old Will Rudd for example (although I still reckon he's a ringer). They'll be dazzled by the '6 screen cinema' like it's the second coming of Christ and not even spare a thought for the total mess HC have made to get there.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
6:53pm Thu 1 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
7:11pm Thu 1 Nov 12
It feels like HC are riding on the back of this assumption and with the spin generated by them, Hereford Futures and Stanhope to an extent, they think they can railroad this one in without anyone realising what's happened.
I'm not stuck in the dark ages, far from it. Hereford desperately needs development but not one that will see subsequent councils (and council tax payers) paying the debt of this off for years to come whilst those who made these monumental decisions are long gone.
The soul is being sold and no one really seems to be bothered by it.
Have you seen The Simpsons 'Monorail' episode? Every time I think of HC/Stanhope it reminds of the sorry debacle when a big time, unscrupulous developer pitches up in small town and convinces them they need a monorail. Mob mentality takes over and everyone gets caught I the spin generated by the developer that the town really needs it. Suffice to say the project is a disaster, the town loses lots of money and the developer disappears into the sunset with a massive wedge of cash.
Lol...that was a bit random :)
Themightyboosh
says...
1:44pm Fri 2 Nov 12
lol lukio that sums this farce up perfectly
littlewhitebull
says...
3:18pm Fri 2 Nov 12
My first thought was that if only that great playwright, Arnold Ridley (Private Godfrey in Dad's Army) was still alive, he would be able to create a great farce at the Courtyard Theatre! Probably, not a great deal of imagination would be needed,
dippyhippy
says...
4:38pm Fri 2 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
7:29pm Fri 2 Nov 12
Perhaps he's finally succumbed to the prescription drugs? I haven't seen any news reports of any one throwing themselves off a public building in Hereford over the last few days either.
My bet is he's continuing in his quest to find Studmarsh or the council henchman have found him out and locked him up in an cattle stall in the old market.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
12:12am Sat 3 Nov 12
fordshire77
says...
9:32am Sat 3 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
10:02am Sat 3 Nov 12
What's the latest and who are we hating now. Is it the Council still?
dippyhippy
says...
10:57am Sat 3 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
11:06am Sat 3 Nov 12
You can no longer jump from a publicly funded building, you can't fiddle about with amphibians without having to ride the lightening bolt and there were two or three other things but I can't remember because the diazepam is kicking in.
My very warmest regards.
littlewhitebull
says...
12:47pm Sat 3 Nov 12
Perhaps, the council could subject them to paying back tax on their habitats? Surely, as the council squander such vast sums on meaningless projects, it is time that they sought to tax all inhabitants of this wonderful county.
Yes, I realise my ideas are far from sensible and very left field. But with our council nothing is impossible - cos, Here We Can!
Colin J Marschall
says...
3:18am Sun 4 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
12:33pm Sun 4 Nov 12
Colin J Marschall
says...
7:32pm Sun 4 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
8:29pm Sun 4 Nov 12
Lukio
says...
9:38am Mon 5 Nov 12
At national level (i.e. Parliament), a 'no confidence' can be motioned by elected members but there is a certain level that must be met before the 'no confidence' can be voted on.
I'm not sure if there are enough IOC or Independant members (or Tory rebels) that would meet the minimum required level that this could be mooted. Or even if this approach is possible at local government level.
I'm tempted to contact IOC or one of the Independants to see if this is an avenue that could be explored.
megilleland
says...
11:10am Mon 5 Nov 12
http://www.herefords
hire.gov.uk/council_
gov_democracy/electi
ons/24611.asp
However the council does not say what the other options are. The information is being withheld - don't want to help local voters too much.
megilleland
says...
11:10am Mon 5 Nov 12
http://www.herefords
hire.gov.uk/council_
gov_democracy/electi
ons/24611.asp
However the council does not say what the other options are. The information is being withheld - don't want to help local voters too much.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
12:43pm Mon 5 Nov 12
bobby47
says...
2:11pm Mon 5 Nov 12
William Rudd
says...
11:54pm Mon 5 Nov 12
And Mark Hubbards IOC is dead in the water,Just look at his facebook page.
Lukio
says...
8:49am Tue 6 Nov 12
I'm sure that the 10,000 people who signed the petition against the council's plans back in 2010 have totally changed their views and perceptions of how well they are doing now.
You continue to astound me with your total ignorance.
And what's wrong with the IOC Facebook page? I see it's regularly updated and healthy discussion taking place so I'm not entirely sure what you're trying to get across.
In comparison I checked the council's Facebook page...oh wait, they haven't got one. They probably don't want to face up to the truth that the majority of people don't agree with what they're doing to the county and the stick they'd get on it. I expect they're happy with their mouthpiece that is the Hereford Futures page to soak up the flak.
And the Tories have a ONE majority on this council - hardly massive is it? Face it William, for the monumental mess they've made of pretty much everything, they'll be down the road next election and good riddance.
WYSIATI
says...
9:09am Tue 6 Nov 12
As for ESG this feels like the Concorde fallacy in miniature - you're so far in you can't stop even when the world changes around you. Timing's everything and what might have been a good idea when things were booming might not be when things are not. But it's a long term thing and might be something to look back on and wonder why it wasn't done sooner - or it might fester and stagnate.
What scares me is that public authorities seem to struggle when contracting with the private sector - PFI was a great scam, in order to keep necessary capital spending off the Govt balance sheet go to the private sector - but the private sector does not have any duty to the public - only to the shareholders. Why would you expect that to result in a good deal?
And now all the talk is of privatising services - buying complex services that are not widgets or temporary envelope fillers is not so simple.
The Olympics showed that a public project can pull it off, G4S showed that crass reliance on a contract (can you supply enough security? - yes - that's ok then). The idea that private is always right and public always wrong is lazy and inadequate.
Once we've mortgaged all our public goods to private enterprise we will be sorry.
Rant over - Bobby47 for president
bobby47
says...
12:02pm Tue 6 Nov 12
We will have a whipping post set up by the Black and White House, Wysiati can tether William to the post as reward for coming up with the idea to make me King and Lukio gets to thrash his nemesis William whenever something goes wrong.
Then, after the punishment has been administered you can all buy a nettle from me the King and if you choose you can approach the badly beaten William and give him a stroke with your nettle leaf.
Make me your King. You'll never regret it.
TwoWheelsGood
says...
1:28pm Tue 6 Nov 12
It seems the only way things will change before the next elections is the loss of a councillor or two - by resignation or demise - which would force a by-election. The tories only need to lose one seat and its game on, much can then be changed if all the non-tories vote together.
Disappointed not to be in the first wave of King Bobby47's appointments, but still hoping for a place on the top table.
bobby47
says...
2:00pm Tue 6 Nov 12
I've got a few positions in mind for you my old dear friend and none involve arson or human sacrifice.
Tell me what you fancy and as long as it don't involve you keeping the silver button for yourself I'll give it some thought.
That said, Lukio gets to keep his job. He'll just love it.
Lukio
says...
2:16pm Tue 6 Nov 12
I definitely think TwoWheels deserves an important role as well as he is one of our like minded kin.
We can only hope that a by-election happens sooner rather than later thus to rebalance the powers a little more sensibly. I do not wish for anyone's demise. Maybe a juicy scandal that leaves one of the Tories no option but to resign :)
bobby47
says...
2:24pm Tue 6 Nov 12
A King needs respect and I'll not tolerate anyone sniggering and muttering, 'The mans a fool' as I get wheeled into High Town in my handcart dressed in my Granny's clothes clutching the recently unearthed silver button bemoaning my clubbed foot, hare lip and a very recent infestation of headlice.
My pledge to you all is an unlimited supply of diazepam to all who are desperate for it, an allotment on the Racecourse, no more gimmicks, no more waste and more importantly, the chance to take part in a weekly trolley dash round lidl's.
How about that then? And there's plenty more where that came from.
bobby47
says...
2:43pm Tue 6 Nov 12
Lets be sensible about how big this table is going to be. Im all for there being a table, Im all for it being sizeable but we can't have it becoming overwhelmingly huge.
Ubique5740
says...
2:51pm Tue 6 Nov 12
TwoWheelsGood
says...
3:14pm Tue 6 Nov 12
As for my important role, I'll take anything, as long as its not the court jester, which surely must be for Mr Rudd. Minister for transport will do, free parking for all bicycles and the kings wheelbarrow will surely follow.
bobby47
says...
8:03pm Tue 6 Nov 12
You are saying that a table you have never seen is bigger than another table you have never seen.
We have to sort this table out now. I'll not agree to become King until I know who is at the table, how many of us are at the top table and can we all fit in around the table.
After I get crowned and get me hands on the silver button, it's no good us all staggering down St.Owen Street, bursting into the Town Hall, racing up the stairs to discover the table does not meet our needs.
Then, what do we do?
cursor says...
10:13am Wed 31 Oct 12